Short answer: the cheapest US physical gold ETFs are IAUM (0.09%) and GLDM (0.10%). A physical trust's tracking gap is almost exactly its fee, so the fee order below is also the long-run tracking order. GLD costs the most but has the deepest market for active trading.
| # | ETF | Expense ratio | Yearly cost on $10,000 | Stands out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IAUM | 0.09% | $9 | Lowest fee |
| 2 | GLDM | 0.10% | $10 | Low fee at scale (~$30.4B) |
| 3= | SGOL | 0.17% | $17 | Swiss vaulting |
| 3= | BAR | 0.17% | $17 | Low fee, smaller fund |
| 5 | IAU | 0.25% | $25 | Large and heavily traded (~$60.9B) |
| 6 | GLD | 0.40% | $40 | Deepest liquidity, options (~$138.6B) |
Ranked by fee: a cost ranking, not a recommendation. Fund assets are mid-October 2026. All six hold allocated physical gold (details); see the top 3 side by side.
Key Takeaways
- Long holds: the fee dominates, which favors IAUM and GLDM. On $100,000 they cost $90 to $100 a year against GLD's $400.
- Very short holds: spread and depth dominate, which is where GLD and IAU earn their place. If each fund quotes one cent wide, GLD's narrower spread only covers its higher fee on round trips of about two to four weeks or less (the math).
- Vault location: SGOL stores its gold mainly in Zurich. The trust and its custodian are still US-linked, so this is geographic diversification, not an escape from US legal reach.
- Accounts: all six can generally be held in an IRA, but confirm with your custodian.
- US tax: long-term gains on physically backed trusts are taxed as collectibles at up to 28%, not the 15% or 20% equity rates. Short-term gains are ordinary income.
Gold ETFs give direct exposure to physical gold in a brokerage account, with no storage to arrange and no dealer premium to pay. They are not identical, though. Expense ratios run from 0.09% to 0.40%, and fund size runs from the smaller trusts up to about $138.6 billion for GLD. Holding GLD instead of IAUM costs an extra 0.31% a year, or $310 on every $100,000.
Full Comparison: Six Physical Gold ETFs
| Metric | IAUM | GLDM | SGOL | BAR | IAU | GLD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Name | iShares Gold Trust Micro | SPDR Gold MiniShares | abrdn Physical Gold Shares ETF | GraniteShares Gold Trust | iShares Gold Trust | SPDR Gold Shares |
| Expense Ratio | 0.09% Lowest | 0.10% | 0.17% | 0.17% | 0.25% | 0.40% |
| AUM (mid-Oct 2026) | Smaller; check sponsor | ~$30.4B | Smaller; check sponsor | Smaller; check sponsor | ~$60.9B | ~$138.6B Largest |
| Gold per Share (approx.) | ~0.01 oz | ~0.02 oz | ~0.0096 oz | ~0.0096 oz | ~0.019 oz | ~0.091 oz |
| Implied Share Value at ~$3,880 Gold | ~$39 | ~$78 | ~$37 | ~$37 | ~$74 | ~$353 |
| Custody | JPMorgan | London; custodian named in prospectus | JPMorgan, mainly Zurich | ICBC Standard Bank, London | JPMorgan, mainly London | HSBC and JPMorgan, London |
| Allocated Storage | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Physical Redemption | All six: Authorized Participants only, in large baskets. Not available to retail holders. | |||||
| IRA | All six: generally available in IRAs at major brokers. Confirm with your custodian. | |||||
| US Tax Treatment | All six: collectibles. Long-term gains up to 28% federal; short-term gains at ordinary rates. | |||||
| Inception | Jun 2021 | Jun 2018 | Sep 2009 | Aug 2017 | Jan 2005 | Nov 2004 |
| Expected Annual Tracking Difference | ≈ −0.09% | ≈ −0.10% | ≈ −0.17% | ≈ −0.17% | ≈ −0.25% | ≈ −0.40% |
Custodians and vault lists can change: the current prospectus is the authority. Sponsors publish the exact gold per share daily.
Are SGOL, IAUM and GLDM Allocated Gold?
Yes. All three are physically backed trusts holding allocated bars: specific bars identified to the trust at the custodian, not a general claim on a bank. Each may hold a small unallocated balance while gold moves through creations, redemptions and fee payments. That is normal for these trusts and is minor relative to the total.
| SGOL | IAUM | GLDM | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.17% | 0.09% | 0.10% |
| Backing | Allocated bars | Allocated bars | Allocated bars |
| Main vault | Zurich | Per prospectus | London |
| Sponsor | abrdn | iShares (BlackRock) | State Street |
| Retail can redeem for bars? | No | No | No |
Allocated does not mean a shareholder owns a numbered bar. You own a share of the trust, and the trust owns the bars. If what you want is metal in your own name, that is a different product: see gold ETF vs physical gold.
Top 3 Gold ETFs Side by Side
These are the three largest funds by assets. They split cleanly on what each is for.
| GLD | IAU | GLDM | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.40% | 0.25% | 0.10% |
| AUM (mid-Oct 2026) | ~$138.6B | ~$60.9B | ~$30.4B |
| Yearly fee on $100,000 | $400 | $250 | $100 |
| 10-year fee on $100,000 | $4,000 | $2,500 | $1,000 |
| Implied share value | ~$353 | ~$74 | ~$78 |
| Backing | Allocated bars | Allocated bars | Allocated bars |
| Main strength | Liquidity, options | Balance of cost and volume | Lowest cost of the three |
| Main weakness | Highest fee | Fee well above the mini funds | Less depth than GLD for very large orders |
Fee totals assume a constant $100,000 balance, with no compounding.
Why the Cheapest Fund Is Also the Best Tracker
Both big sponsors run a low-cost "mini" fund for buy-and-hold investors, and those sit at the bottom of the fee table. For a physical gold trust, tracking difference against spot is close to the expense ratio plus a sliver of trust costs. So the fee ranking at the top of this page doubles as a tracking-difference ranking over long periods. Over short periods the bid-ask spread matters more than the fee. Sponsors do change fees, so check each fund's own page before buying.
Individual ETF Profiles
True Cost of Ownership: 10-Year Analysis
Here is the fee on a constant $100,000 position with gold flat. It is simple multiplication, which isolates the cost difference; in practice the fee is charged on a changing balance.
| ETF | Annual Fee on $100K | 5-Year Cost | 10-Year Cost | vs. IAUM over 10 Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IAUM | $90 | $450 | $900 | — |
| GLDM | $100 | $500 | $1,000 | +$100 |
| SGOL | $170 | $850 | $1,700 | +$800 |
| BAR | $170 | $850 | $1,700 | +$800 |
| IAU | $250 | $1,250 | $2,500 | +$1,600 |
| GLD | $400 | $2,000 | $4,000 | +$3,100 |
On a $10,000 position, the 10-year gap between GLD and IAUM is $310. That is real money but small next to the price risk in gold itself. On $1,000,000 it is $31,000, which is hard to justify for a strategic hold unless you need GLD's liquidity or options.
Tracking Error, Tracking Difference, and Bid-Ask Spread
A physical gold ETF sells a sliver of its bullion each year to pay the sponsor fee, so its net asset value drifts below spot by about the expense ratio. That drift is the tracking difference. The volatility of the gap against the gold price is the tracking error. For a physical trust both are small: there is no basket to replicate, nothing to rebalance and no dividends. If a gold product shows a much larger gap, it is usually not a physical trust. It is more likely a futures-based fund carrying roll cost, or a leveraged product that resets daily.
Spread is the other cost. A one-cent spread is a different percentage on each fund, because share values differ:
| ETF | Expense Ratio | Expected Annual Tracking Difference | One Cent as % of Implied Share Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| IAUM | 0.09% | ≈ −0.09% | 0.026% |
| GLDM | 0.10% | ≈ −0.10% | 0.013% |
| SGOL | 0.17% | ≈ −0.17% | 0.027% |
| BAR | 0.17% | ≈ −0.17% | 0.027% |
| IAU | 0.25% | ≈ −0.25% | 0.014% |
| GLD | 0.40% | ≈ −0.40% | 0.003% |
This table shows what one cent means, not a quoted spread. Smaller funds can be wider than one cent, especially at the open and close.
When the spread outweighs the fee
A round trip costs one spread. If GLD and GLDM each quote one cent wide, GLD saves about 0.010% per round trip but costs 0.30% more per year. The spread saving pays for about 12 days of the extra fee. Against IAU the figure is about 26 days, and against IAUM about 27 days. So on these assumptions GLD is only cheaper on round trips of about two to four weeks or less. Beyond that the lower-fee funds win, unless their real spreads are wider or your size is large enough to move the book.
| Holding Period | Cost Driver That Dominates | Lowest Cost, in Principle |
|---|---|---|
| Days to a few weeks, frequent trading | Bid-ask spread and depth | GLD, then IAU |
| A month to a year | Fee starts to outweigh spread | GLDM or IAUM, using limit orders |
| Several years, buy and hold | Expense ratio | IAUM or GLDM |
| Large single purchase, long hold | Fee, plus depth on entry | GLDM combines scale with a low fee |
Premium and discount to NAV
An ETF's market price can trade slightly above or below the value of its gold. Authorized Participants arbitrage that gap by creating or redeeming baskets. In the largest funds it tends to close quickly. In smaller funds it can last longer, which is a second, less visible cost for anyone trading in size. Sponsors publish premium and discount history, and that is worth a look before choosing between two funds on the same fee.
Gold ETF Performance and Structural Changes in 2026
Physical gold ETFs did what spot gold did, less the fee. Spot peaked at $5,595.42 on January 29, ended March near $4,700 and April near $4,650, with an April average of about $4,770. As of October 30, 2026, it was about $3,880: about 11% down for the year and about 31% below the high. Fund returns followed. See why gold is falling and the monthly averages.
Fund choice mattered far less than gold itself. Over the first ten months of the year, the fee drag ran from about 0.08% for IAUM to about 0.33% for GLD. Gold's own move was in double digits. Check each sponsor's fact sheet for exact fund returns.
On structure, we found no fee changes at IAUM, GLDM, SGOL, IAU, GLD or BAR, in April or through mid-October 2026. Sponsors can change fees, so two things are worth re-checking each quarter: the published expense ratio, and fund assets, because sustained outflows can widen a small fund's spread. Custodian, vault location and the allocated structure usually stay put for years, but the prospectus is the place to confirm them.
Tax Treatment: The Collectibles Rule
In the US, physically backed grantor-trust ETFs such as GLD, IAU, IAUM, GLDM, SGOL and BAR are treated as collectibles. In practice:
- Held over a year: gains are taxed at your ordinary rate, capped at 28% federal
- Held a year or less: gains are taxed as ordinary income, the same as for a stock
- The usual 15% and 20% long-term rates do not apply
- The 3.8% net investment income tax can apply on top for higher earners, and most states tax gains as well
For an investor in the 37% bracket, a $50,000 long-term gain costs $14,000 in federal tax at 28%, against $10,000 at 20%. That $4,000 gap is the reason some investors prefer to hold gold ETFs in an IRA.
IRA Strategy
Inside an IRA the collectibles rate does not apply while the money stays in the account. In a Roth IRA, qualified withdrawals are tax-free. In a traditional IRA, withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, which can be worse than 28% for high earners. The right account depends on your expected tax bracket in retirement.
The Decision Framework: Which ETF Should You Choose?
Match Your Situation to the Right Fund
Alternatives to Physical Gold ETFs
Before working through the alternatives below, it is worth being clear on how each one is priced. Gold futures, in particular, quote differently from the spot price that ETFs track — see our guide to gold futures vs the spot price for why the two never match.
Gold ETFs are not the only way to invest in gold. Here is where they fit in the broader investment landscape:
| Investment Type | Exposure | Leverage | Best For | Key Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Physical Gold ETF (GLD, IAU, etc.) | 1:1 to gold price | None | Core allocation, IRAs, long-term holds | Collectibles tax; no physical possession |
| Physical Bars/Coins | 1:1 to gold price | None | Systemic hedge, no counterparty risk | Premiums (typically 1.5–5.5% on 1 oz products); storage costs; less liquid |
| Gold Miners ETF (GDX, GDXJ) | Often a multiple of gold's move, both ways | Operational leverage | Higher-risk exposure to the gold price and to company earnings | Management risk; mine costs; political risk |
| Gold Futures (COMEX) | Direct; rollover required | High (margin is a small % of notional) | Hedging; professional traders | Roll costs; margin calls; complexity |
| Gold Streaming Companies (RGLD, WPM) | Indirect; equity exposure | Financial leverage | Dividend income + gold exposure | Company-specific risk; premium valuation |
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources: spot and silver reference: USAGOLD, October 30, 2026, fund assets and fees: fund sponsors, which remain the authority.
Disclaimer: This guide is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Expense ratios, AUM figures, and trading data change frequently and should be verified before any investment decision. Gold ETFs carry investment risk including potential loss of principal. Past tracking error does not guarantee future performance. Tax treatment described is based on US federal tax law as of October 2026 and may change. Consult a qualified financial and tax advisor before investing.